The camera club judge can be considered in the same light as a reviewer or critic of movies, books or other art forms. He should have a knowledge of the subject and be able to articulate specifics about the work. The primary purpose of the review is to educate. Certain criteria is established for each photography show and, after meeting the criteria, what remains is a subjective appraisal of the work. The judge should be qualified by way of knowledge and experience and with this background be able make informed selections and offer constructive criticisms in a helpful and inspiring manner.

Criteria I would use as a camera club judge

My first consideration would be conformity with the rules of the competition. Next would be the three C’s – craftsmanship, composition and creativity. The judging should be a learning experience for everyone involved, including the judge. Negative aspects should be minimized while focusing on the positive attributes of the work. Originality, uniqueness, feeling, mood and capturing the moment would hold a prominent place in the selection criteria.